Second Half_1, Columbus, Arfsten, 5 (Hernandez), 55th minute; 2, New York Red Bulls, Vanzeir, 5 (Forsberg), 64th; 3, New York Red Bulls, Forsberg, 10 (penalty kick), 80th; 4, Columbus, Ramirez, 9 ...
Columbus scored on their first four penalty kick attempts, putting pressure on New York. Needing a goal to extend the shootout, Red Bulls forward Elias Manoel scored to the lower right side of the net ...